Mobile Tech Today

CIO Today Network Sites:   Top Tech News  |   CIO Today   |   Mobile Tech Today   |   Data Storage Today
News & Product Reviews for Mobile Tech Users
Friday, April 18th 
Real-time info services with Neustar
This ad will display for the next 20 seconds. Please click for more information, or scroll down to pass the ad, or Close Ad.
Trending Topics:   Security Heartbleed Big Data Cloud Computing Windows XP Data Centers OS X Mavericks
Home
Laptops & Tablets
Mobile Phones
Mobile Gadgets
Mobile Apps
BYOD & MDM
iPad
Mobile Industry News
Wireless Connectivity
Wireless Security
GPS & Maps
MTT Press Releases
 
Free Newsletters
Top CIO News
 
Mobile Tech Today
 

Mobile Industry News

Judge Throws Apple-Motorola Patent Claims Out of Court

Judge Throws Apple-Motorola Patent Claims Out of Court
June 8, 2012 2:58PM

Bookmark and Share
Of both Apple's and Motorola's patent claims, U.S. District Judge Richard Posner said the imposition of injunctive relief would impose disproportionate costs on the alleged patent infringer as well as distribute disproportionate benefits to the patent holder. Such a decision, he wrote, would also "be contrary to the public interest."

Your Next Generation Data Center Is Here! Vblock™ Systems: the world's most advanced converged infrastructure are built on the Cisco Unified Computing System with Intel® Xeon® processors. Vblock™ Systems deliver extraordinary time to market, ROI and TCO, and flexibility to meet your continually changing demands with 5X faster deployment, 96% less downtime, and 1/2 the cost. Click here to learn more.

A judge has dismissed claims and counterclaims by Apple and Motorola Mobility over patent infringement, canceling their jury trial in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois just days before it was scheduled to begin.

In a preliminary opinion on the lawsuits, Judge Richard Posner said both sides in the patent dispute over smartphone and tablet technology should have their claims dismissed with prejudice because neither party had established a right to relief. The finding would prevent the two sides from bringing a similar suit in the future.

Posner said, however, that he was delaying entry of final judgment until he had prepared a full opinion.

After disallowing two of Apple's patent claims on May 22, Posner tentatively concluded that Apple's admissible evidence of damages with respect to the remaining patents under dispute did not "create a genuine issue of material fact" that would enable Apple's remaining claims to withstand Motorola Mobility's motion for summary judgment.

"I likewise tentatively conclude that the admissible evidence of damages with respect to the alleged infringement by Apple of Motorola's 898 patent also fails to create a genuine issue of material fact," Posner wrote in the preliminary order issued Thursday.

Google's Long-Term Dilemma

Posner said the imposition of injunctive relief would impose disproportionate costs on the alleged patent infringer as well as distribute disproportionate benefits to the patent holder. Such a decision, he wrote, would also "be contrary to the public interest."

"But all this requires a fuller explanation, which I will endeavor to provide in my opinion," Posner said. "I expect to issue it within a week."

Google cleared all regulatory hurdles for closing its acquisition of Motorola Mobility last month under a $12.5 billion offer tendered last year. With respect to Google's huge investment in Motorola and its ambitions to stop Apple's intellectual-property assertions against Android, Posner's decision is "a setback," said FOSS Patents blogger Florian Mueller.

Though it is in Motorola's interest to avoid the four patent claims Apple was asserting in Chicago, "in the greater scheme of things, it also means that Google won't be able to win any ruling in the U.S. against Apple before 2014 other than an International Trade Commission decision -- which is increasingly unlikely to be the import ban it requested," Mueller wrote Thursday.

An Influential Opinion

Posner normally serves as a member of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit in Chicago. Industry observers have interpreted his temporary reassignment to specifically adjudicate the Apple vs. Motorola dispute before the Illinois district court as a sign that the U.S. judicial system wanted the court's ruling to serve as a benchmark for future patent disputes.

Though Apple and Google have the option of appealing the final opinion, Posner's ruling is likely to carry considerable weight. Among other things, Posner is the author of 40 books on jurisprudence, economics and other topics as well as a professor at the University of Chicago. And according to The Journal of Legal Studies, Posner, a former president of the Harvard Law Review, is also most cited legal scholar of the 20th century.

Earlier this week, Posner obliquely referred to the tsunami of electronic industry patent lawsuits swamping U.S. courts in a blog he shares with Gary Becker, a professor of economics and sociology at the University of Chicago. Noting that the institutional structure of the United States is under stress, Posner cited the nation's "dysfunctional patent system" as one of the major issues that "needs a lot of work to achieve proper capitalist goals."

Tell Us What You Think
Comment:

Name:

patent litigation:

Posted: 2012-06-18 @ 2:32am PT
Posner's ruling last week seemed like a signal from the courts that corporations need to start being a little more sensible about all of these patent suits. I hope he sticks to his guns; the patent wars have gotten out of control, and are now effectively serving as a proxy for marketplace competition.
http://www.generalpatent.com/blog



 Mobile Industry News
1. Malware Targets Facebook Users
2. Intel Reports Lower 1Q Net Income
3. Samsung Tech Experts Talk Patents
4. Zebra Buys Motorola Enterprise Biz
5. Google's Modular Phone Set for January




 Most Popular Articles
1. HP Rolls Out New Software-Defined Network Products
2. Smartphone Kill Switch Could Save Users $2.6B a Year
3. Google Glass Finds a Home in Medical Education, Practice
4. Avaya Aims To End Network Waiting Game
5. Google Video Shows Off Modular Project Ara Phone


Have an informed opinion on this story?
Send a Letter to the Editor.
We want to know what you think.
Send us your Feedback.

 Related Topics  Latest News & Special Reports

  Google Street View Unravels CAPTCHAs
  Android Gets Chrome Remote Desktop
  Malware Targets Facebook Users
  Intel Reports Lower 1Q Net Income
  Samsung Tech Experts Talk Patents

 Technology Marketplace

Business Intelligence
Get real-time, cloud-based information services with Neustar.
 
Cloud Computing
BMC's I.T. solutions unleash the power of your business
Next Generation Data Center Is Here! Vblock™ Systems from VCE
 
Contact Centers
HP delivers the future of the contact center with HP Qfiniti 10.
 
Data Storage
Next Generation Data Center Is Here! Vblock™ Systems from VCE
Barium Ferrite (BaFe) is the future of tape.
2.5" Enterprise-class SATA & SAS SSDs for server & storage applications
 
Enterprise Hardware
Barium Ferrite (BaFe) is the future of tape.
2.5" Enterprise-class SATA & SAS SSDs for server & storage applications
 
Enterprise I.T.
BMC's I.T. solutions unleash the power of your business
 
Hardware
Protect your network with APC Smart-UPS battery backup
 
Network Security
Protect your network with APC Smart-UPS battery backup
 

Network Security Spotlight
Google's Street View Software Unravels CAPTCHAs
The latest software Google uses for its Street View cars to read street numbers in images for Google Maps works so well that it also solves CAPTCHAs, those puzzles designed to defeat bots.
 
Canadian Teen Arrested for Heartbleed Hack
One week after the OpenSSL Heartbleed vulnerability was unveiled, Canadian authorities have made the first arrest -- a London, Ontario teenager -- connected to exploiting the security hole.
 
IBM Offers Security, Disaster Recovery as SoftLayer Service
New disaster recovery and security services for SoftLayer clients are being added by IBM. Big Blue said the new capabilities will speed cloud adoption by alleviating concern over business continuity.
 

Enterprise Hardware Spotlight
Vaio Fit 11A Battery Danger Forces Recall by Sony
Using a Sony Vaio Fit 11A laptop? It's time to send it back to Sony. In fact, Sony is encouraging people to stop using the laptop after several reports of its Panasonic battery overheating.
 
Continued Drop in Global PC Shipments Slows
Worldwide shipments of PCs fell during the first three months of the year, but the global slump in PC demand may be easing, with a considerable slowdown from last year's drops.
 
Google Glass Finds a Home in Medical Education, Practice
Google Glass may find its first markets in verticals in which hands-free access to data is a boon. Medicine is among the most prominent of those, as seen in a number of Glass experiments under way.
 

Mobile Technology Spotlight
Google Releases Chrome Remote Desktop App for Android
You're out on a sales call, and use your Android mobile device to grab a file you have back at the office on your desktop. That's a bit easier now with Google's Chrome Remote Desktop app for Android.
 
Amazon 3D Smartphone Pics Leaked
E-commerce giant Amazon is reportedly set to launch a smartphone after years of development. Photos of the phone, which may feature a unique 3D interface, were leaked by tech pub BGR.
 
Zebra Tech Buys Motorola Enterprise for $3.45B
Weeks after Lenovo bought Motorola Mobility’s assets from Google for $2.91 billion, Zebra Technologies is throwing down $3.45 billion for Motorola’s Enterprise business in an all-cash deal.
 

Navigation
Mobile Tech Today
Home/Top News | Laptops & Tablets | Mobile Phones | Mobile Gadgets | Mobile Apps | BYOD & MDM | iPad
Mobile Industry News | Wireless Connectivity | Wireless Security | GPS & Maps | MTT Press Releases
Also visit these Enterprise Technology Sites
Top Tech News | CIO Today | Mobile Tech Today | Data Storage Today

Services:
FreeNewsFeed | Free Newsletters | XML/RSS Feed

About CIO Today Network | How To Contact Us | Article Reprints | Services for PR Pros (In partnership with NewsFactor) | Top Tech Wire | How To Advertise

Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
© Copyright 2000-2014 Mobile Tech Today. All rights reserved. Article rating technology by Blogowogo. Member of Accuserve Ad Network.